Recommended Posts

Kinah 22: Desperate Measures

In this elegy composed by an unknown author describing the anguish of a survivor of an unknown massacred community we share the pain of countless communities and individuals who have suffered the tortures of exile over the ages.

The Kinah describes the weeping of all the angels. Perhaps we can add an element by sharing a Responsum that resulted from one such massacre:

In his most poignant responsum (Part II #59) the Maharam MiRothenbeurg discusses a case arising out of the tragic events which occurred in the city of Koblenz, where on April 2, 1265, some twenty Jews were slaughtered. At that time a man killed his wife and four children by his own hand in order to save them from torture and forcible conversion. He had intended to kill himself, but was saved by Gentiles before he could commit suicide.

The Maharam was asked whether the unfortunate man was obliged to do penance for the murder of his family.

The Maharam first observes that he has no doubt at all that suicide is permitted if the aim is to avoid forcible conversion to another faith. The Midrash (Bereishit Rabbah 34:19) explicitly exempts from the sin of suicide instances such as that of King Saul who killed himself in order to avoid being tortured by the Philistines. (Samuel I 31:3-5) And the Talmud (Gittin 57b) quotes with approval the tale of the young men and women being taken to Rome for immoral purposes, who threw themselves into the sea.

All this, however, applies only to suicide. The Maharam is not at all sure that it is permitted to murder others for the sake of the “Sanctification of God’s Name,” in order to prevent them being forcibly converted.

The Maharam, nevertheless, concludes that this, too, must be permitted, since we know that many of the righteous did kill themselves and their families when threatened with forced conversion.

Consequently, no penance is required because no sin was committed. On the contrary, the man must not be allowed to undergo any penance, for if he did penance it would imply that he was wrong, and that the righteous of old were wrong.

Author Info:
Learn & discover the Divine prophecies with Rabbi Simcha Weinberg from the holy Torah, Jewish Law, Mysticism, Kabbalah and Jewish Prophecies. The Foundation Stone is the ultimate resource for Jews, Judaism, Jewish Education, Jewish Spirituality & the holy Torah.

Go Back to Previous Page

  • Other visitors also read